As South Africans prepare for end-of-year performance reviews and salary discussions, a recruitment expert is urging employees to rethink how they approach requests for a pay increase. Relying solely on the rising cost of living may not be enough to persuade an employer.
However, with South Africa’s unemployment rate reaching 33.6% in the second quarter of 2026, employees may feel hesitant to negotiate, even when their responsibilities have grown, or their contributions warrant better remuneration.
Sharon Armstrong, recruitment expert and founder of Armstrong Appointments, shares four practical ways employees can strengthen their case for a salary increase, along with common mistakes to avoid when approaching these conversations.
1. Don’t make rising living costs your main argument
While the rising cost of living is an understandable reason for wanting a higher salary, it is unlikely to be the strongest argument from an employer’s perspective. “It’s completely understandable that people want more money when everything around them is getting more expensive. The problem is that your manager may be facing those same financial pressures within the business.
“Rather than making the conversation about what you need to earn, show how your contribution has changed. If you’ve taken on additional responsibilities or helped the company achieve something important, that’s a much stronger starting point.” Sharon recommends compiling a record of achievements from the past year, highlighting measurable results, improvements in productivity, additional responsibilities, and contributions that extend beyond the original job description.
2. Understand what your role is worth in the market
Going into a salary discussion without understanding current market-related remuneration can weaken an employee’s negotiating position. “Many people go into salary discussions without knowing what someone doing a similar job earns elsewhere. That can leave them asking for too little or making a request that’s difficult to justify.
“Look at comparable vacancies and salary surveys, but pay attention to the experience required and where the jobs are based. Two positions with the same title can come with very different expectations.” Employees should also evaluate their overall remuneration package, including benefits, bonuses and other incentives, rather than focusing exclusively on their basic salary.
3. Don’t wait until your annual performance review to raise the subject
Another common mistake is assuming that an annual performance review is the first opportunity to discuss remuneration. “By the time your annual review comes around, your company’s salary budget might already have been agreed.
“If you’re hoping for an increase in the new year, raise the subject early enough for your manager to consider it. Even a short conversation about your expectations can give them time to investigate what’s possible.”
Starting the conversation early allows employers to consider salary expectations as part of their budgeting and remuneration planning, rather than being presented with an unexpected request during the review process.
4. Be prepared for the answer to be no
Not every salary increase request will be successful, but a rejection does not necessarily mean there is no opportunity for future growth. Sharon advises employees to approach a negative response constructively rather than resorting to ultimatums or threats to resign.
“If your manager says there’s no room for an increase, ask what would need to change for that conversation to happen again. “Try to leave with something specific, whether that’s a target to work towards or a date to review your salary. Otherwise, it’s easy to find yourself having the same conversation six months later.”
If an immediate salary increase isn’t possible, employees could also explore alternative options, such as additional benefits, professional development, training opportunities, or agreeing on a future salary review.
“People sometimes spend months feeling underpaid without ever having the conversation. There’s nothing wrong with asking to be paid fairly for the work you’re doing, but going in prepared gives your employer a much clearer reason to take the request seriously.”
